PP Laser Weapons overpower and game changers!

Yes WP bonus on heads will help a lot.
I would have chosen another way of doing it. Like increasining +1 Max WP with each level. So it scales with level.

I think I agree n what you say about heads. Offensive priest could have more armor.

I would even be bolder and make heads complement abilities evolving them and specializing the priest:

  • Screaming head: This head would increase induce panic range, and have screaming as a specific ability. But the other way around, making scream the base ability works too.
  • Synod: This should be a support head, increasing the range of mind sense and ward, with frenzy a speciffic ability.
  • Judgement: this should be the MC head, increasing range of MC, with an speciffic ability to vampirize WP from a target unit, or something fun like that.

Heads could keep or rework the flat bonus, to adjust better for the intended roles.

Regarding viral guns, I would just remove them, or replace them with something else, like some limb mutations. They feel kind of pointless to me as they are. Maybe reworking them with added shook damage will make them useful. Many different things could be done here to make them actually worth using.

1 Like

Snapshot Games is not really pursuing to implement these changes. It is more likely that they will end up in some fan mod to better balance combat.

Of course these proposals may influence some SG decisions to provide some nerfs just as needed Destiny nerf, but it is hard to say what will be changed and how.

So you are saying that viral damage is weak alternative? :slightly_smiling_face: Thanks God that you don’t design this game.

These weapons are powerful enough to make strong enemies go into panic mode. With lesser enemies priest usually can deal otherwise without resort to these weapons.

Im aware that Scyllas can be chessed with viral guns (and paralysis). Which has nothing to do with these weapons being useful for their intended purpose, well balanced or fun to use.

In a wise move Scyllas have now viral resistance. Which should remove the issue of them being very strong against strong enemies. Remaining only the issue of them being very weak against every other enemy in the game, and not very usefull to lower the will of enemies to use abilities on them. Which is what I think they are designed to do.

Also I find strange that u took the only part of my post where I plainly said that I am unsure on what the solution would be to make Viral guns interesting, if any, ignored the actual proposal I made and just run with it as viral guns was what my post was about.

Thanks for the useful comment I guess.
I don’t think its an useful aproach in a discussion, but you do you.

Point is, CC should probably be the intermediate between players and devs. Its obvious they know the game and some of the proposed changes should actually be implemented.

Problem is, and it is a problem. When CC is obsessed to remove exploits and make the game harder to the point their ideas about balance include only and exclusively a long list of nerfs for the side of the player.

That is not what i think balance means, and that aproach to balance does not represent the comunity of players, but a small section of players with only one concern. Making the game more realist, difficult, hardcore, or whatever u want to call it.

The fact that the CC official proposal is a single issue proposal and ignores any concerns related to frustration; difficulty; difficulty progression; unfairness; pacing, accesibility; viability or usefulness of certain classes, factions, weapons or abilities; or fun is a problem. And imo, has contributed to the game being so polarizing, with such a low rate of long term players and such a high rate of frustrated players.

That was one document specifically aimed at specific balance issues. Not all CC members were in total agreement. The other I issues you mention have also been voiced in other CC documents and discussions.

CC are just community, unpaid QA; and devs don’t give a shit about player ideas. CC isn’t what we all thought it will be and for broader community are pretty much useless. :slight_smile:

(They also fill the role of non-existent community manager, advocating the shit SG does :P)

Im aware, not blaming anyone. It is just the way it is. Its only natural a certain profile is overrepresented. I myself was offered being a part of CC a couple of times, the only reason Im not is because the process stopped midpoint and got stuck on SG side for some reason, likely overwork from the person in charge.

I also think this is unfair and demonstrably false. Even if dont agree with all changes. Its obvious most if not all changes on last patchs come from changes players asked for.

I don’t hink this is true either. While many CC have argued in favor of SG, most if not every time they have done so, they did using reason and facts and argue from their personal opinions and experiences. Also some of the harshest criticisms against SG I have seen came from CC themselves.

What I said is that the overwhelming majority of the most vocal voices in the community, forums and CC, in some particular issues. Come from a specific niche of players, with one sided interest that, while valid. Lack a wider perspective.

Despite this, Devs and CC themselves are not ignorant of this bias. And as the last patch shows well, the are really trying to improve the game, not only for veterans but for everybody.

Which is why these discussions, even if sometimes unreconcilable. Are always useful as they show us different perspectives of different people.

1 Like

Im aware, of both things. I think it was a bit of a branding issue.

A discussed CC proposal to remove exploits or OP combos is absolutely fine.

An official CC balance proposal whith a big section focussed on those issues also would make all sense in the world.

An official CC balance proposal, focussed only on removing exploits and nerfs, it is an oversight. And for good or bad, I think reveals what the priorities of most CC are in terms of balance.

This was what I wantet to point. As I really don’t think those are the most important issues for the vast majority of players.

These discussions are, sorry, absolutely worthless as this forum is, and always was, dead to SG. Some just refuse to acknowledge it. :man_shrugging:

No, that was just TL;DR version and I am tired of elaborating somethimg that is fact to me. :man_shrugging: You don’t have to agree and I don’t have the will to convince anyone.

The whole sentence? I have no idea, and I don’t care, what Valygar has on his contract but he is anything but Community Manager. Unless he is master of hidden dragon crouching tiger way of managing community by not giving a shit what community does. Mike, the CC leader (unofficial leader afaik) and some other CC minions fill his role. :man_shrugging:

It is not. So viral weapons are still strong against them. You just need some more shots to affect these few subspecies (and they come really late).

I dont hink we have the same opinion on what means useful.

Sharing ideas is always useful. Having nice conversations about common interests is useful.

SG may not direclt look a lot into the forums. Some SG people certainly does. CC members do, players who vote and request features in the feedback tool do.

All those sources ate considered by SG. Even if you dont think they are.

The all is pointless aproach is a bit too cynic and hopeles for my taste. But also is useless.

If u are right nothing we say matters, so why are u here wasting our time? Is also a bit weird, to say that in a post asking for a game nerf that was actually addresed and implemented by the devs, mid-discussion.

1 Like

The document says exactly what is and what it is not. One thing it’s not is “official”.

If you are wondering why it is in the wiki, it’s purely for convenience of the person who was drafting it (me) (there was a lot discussing for each item and I was giving the wording that all participants found agreeable). There are no links to it from the wiki, but as there is nothing covered by the NDA in it, there is no problem with it being public.

In fact, I’m very happy that it is, because every time somebody says “you CC guys want to nerf everything, everything is OP for you, etc.” I can just point to it and say “it’s not everything, it’s this stuff and here is why”.

Please also note that this document is solely about nerfing, as it says literally in the first paragraph:

“This is an attempt at identifying OP skills (and a few other items in the tactical layer), describing why they are OP and presenting suggestions.”

So the reason why it’s only nerfing is because that’s its purpose. We were trying to answer a common discussion point/question: what items are OP and why?

(Having said that, regarding quite a few items the issue is that it’s too strong in a meta combo and not interesting outside of it, so what we ask there is often a change, more than a nerf)

At other times we discuss other suggestions and balance changes… Like, idk, buffing certain mutations and bionics, or handguns, or nerfing BFMG… :wink:

1 Like

Oh, the blissful ignorance. :slight_smile:

I think we are talking pass each other. I ackd everything u say. And speciffic words aside. CC discussed and placed in the wiki a balance propossal. The only issue and focus of the proposal was to discuss OP combinations and propose nerfs to solve them.

That is the point. The fact that nerfs was the only discussed topic in such detail by the CC is the point.

Whatever the reasons, CC decided to call it a balance proposal. And for whatever reason they decided to only address nerfs, and to not address any other topic related to balance in any other document. Also in the context of the trajectory of the game. Is fair to say, the issue has been a priority for CC.

In my opinion it has been too much of a priority. And also in my opinion many other aspects of the game had been left unadressed for far too long. May those two things be related?, i dont know, because we cant know such things. But i think so. Which would point to SG being inexperienced, certainly not to SG not listening to the community.

Oh believe me, we discuss a lot more things. Even buffs from last patch was kind of reported by us. But we just don’t create wiki page for each topic we discuss.

And believe me, even this wiki page is not the opinion of the whole council. For me these skills, may be main balance issues, but surely not all of them, and definitely I’m not pleased by the solutions proposed there.

2 Likes

Im sorry to say, claiming other people are wrong does not make u right

U are asuming whats in other peoples minds bassed on your experience. That is wrong and unfair.

U can say whatever u want about something being a fact to you. That is not how facts work. Either something is true or it isnt. And u are stating bad faith and lack of care on the part of the devs, based on your feelings and on your perception.

When I present an example of something showing they do care, which is they actually implementing what people in this forum discuss and requests. U dont even try to address it, just flat out act as this never happens.

Whatever u think they don’t care about or what they do, their actions are not evidence of them not caring. And u have no objective reason to support that. So be dissapointed with the game as much as u want.

Just don’t speak on the bad intentions of people u don’t actually know.

Yet you have no idea if what you are saying is true or not. You just spark with optimism and assumption of best SG will. I don’t. :slight_smile:

Drages was banned/muted for sharing NDAed info. That meas it was true info. :slight_smile:

This is not how it works.

Point 1.

U are the one accusing the devs of bad faith and lack of care. U have the burden of Prof and u need to provide evidence for the devs not acting like devs are suppose to act, which is the null hypothesis.

Point 2.

Either the Community feedback is worthless or it isn’t.

If the community feedback is worthless SG would not implement any change suggested by the community.

If the community feedback is not worthless, u would see at least some of the community feedback addresed by the dev.

U are just sitting in a post with a request that has just been addresed by the devs… On this patch alone dozens of requests by the community have been addresed. … Sit on that thought for a second.

U do not only have the burden of proof. U have no evidence to support your position and instead, there is evidence against it.

So, yes I am the one holding an unreasonable position here…

Not CC; me. I placed it in the wiki because it was easier for me to manage it in the wiki than in a spreadsheet.

Well thank you, but again that’s mostly on me. I like wiki and I like precision.

But in terms of CC, you are reading too much into this to extract a significance that it doesn’t have. We discuss all sorts of stuff, and sometimes put it in spreadsheets with a lot of detail.

However, if you want my opinion on balancing, I believe that nerfing the player is mostly the way to go to improve tactical in situations when tactical challenge is trivialized by a skill/item that the player has access to.

I don’t care what you consider evidence. :slight_smile: I have long lasting impression that: “They. Do. Not. Fucking. Care.”. The only people they respond to is CC, as they are their QA - so yeah, they might fix something you consider here as a proof of them responding to your feedback, but the whole point of creating CC in a first place was so they don’t have to. :stuck_out_tongue: I am here longer than you (this isn’t an argument, just stating the fact) and I remember acidgate and the reason why UV/SG came with idea of CC and there is ongoing shit-giving-fest since then. :slight_smile: Burden of proof, good one. This company is one huge burden. :stuck_out_tongue:

Ackowledge that this forum purpose was only to fulfil backers promise. And it is dead as fuck since then (UV till acidgate tried a bit to advocate the, now former, employer but as he said he now works for reputable developer in the UK who care for their staff and customers and he loves it, he doesn’t have as good opinion about SG as you), with you guys (with above mentioned CC members the most) filling the role of “community managers” here for those few and rare, apparently lost, new members. :slight_smile:

And of course CC. They are the only “worthy” of talking to anyone, even if door-man, on a SG payroll. But, their prime objective is to test stuff so they will avoid new acidgate in a first place. They may (or may not) take a chance and opportunity of convincing devs to do something, yet they also may or may not give a shit about community :P. They don’t catalyse community ideas to propose them to devs (what we all thought CC will do). Hell no, they only propose the ideas they personaly agree with. Like the Mikes experiment about 3 AP (shitty one if I may express eloquently myself, one of the worst here). If he’ll be happy with the result, he will propose it to devs, with or without out agreement. They are The Community for SG, not this worthless forum members (worthless forum, not worthless members of forum - I am not as sociopath). :man_shrugging:

Seriously, it isn’t hard to ack. that there is something not right if even the so called community manager doesn’t give a shit about what you talk here about, right? :stuck_out_tongue: He’s here, serves as a tech support if you have missed your key or can’t download a game, but otherwise ignore those long topics he should join. :stuck_out_tongue:

Late edit:

I don’t care anymore, not at all, what you and others think about me or what I say. :slight_smile: I just visit you once a while as a reminder of what a desolated place this forum have become. :man_shrugging: